Running your first Pathfinder 2e session as a GM

A practical guide for first-time Pathfinder 2e Game Masters: preparing, session zero, the three modes of play, setting DCs, running combat and keeping the table happy.

Running a game for the first time is nerve-racking, and Pathfinder Second Edition's thick rulebooks do not help. The good news is that you need far less of those rules than you think, and the game gives you good tools for the parts that matter. This guide covers what to prepare, how to start, and how to keep a first session moving, from someone who would rather you ran a messy, fun game than never ran one at all.

Start small

For a first game, pick something short. A published beginner adventure or a one-shot is ideal: the encounters are balanced, the maps are drawn and the story has a clear end. If you write your own, aim for one location, one problem, two or three fights and a couple of chances to talk or explore. You can always expand it into a campaign later.

Level 1 is the easiest place to start for everyone. Characters have few options, so turns are quick, and everyone learns together.

Session zero

Before the first real session, get everyone together to make characters and agree how the game will work. Talk about the tone (heroic, gritty, silly), any topics people want kept out of the game, how often you will play, and which optional rules you will use, such as Free Archetype. Make sure the party has some reason to be together and roughly covers healing, front-line fighting and skills. Ten minutes on this saves hours of trouble later.

What to prepare

The three modes of play

Pathfinder 2e divides play into three modes, and switching between them is most of a GM's job.

Initiative is usually a Perception check, but it can be a skill that fits what the character was doing: Stealth if they were sneaking, Deception if they were bluffing when the fight broke out. That small rule makes exploration choices matter.

Setting DCs

When a player tries something, you need a Difficulty Class. For quick decisions, a simple scale works well: 10 for something an untrained person could manage, 15 for a task that needs training, 20 for an expert's work, 30 for a master's and 40 for a legendary feat. For tasks tied to a level, such as an obstacle in a level 3 dungeon, the rulebooks list a DC for each level. Do not agonise; a quick, consistent DC is better than a perfect one.

Remember that results have four degrees: critical success, success, failure and critical failure. Beating the DC by 10 or more is a critical success; missing by 10 or more is a critical failure. Let those results mean something extra, good or bad.

Running combat

Keeping the table happy

Watch for quiet players and give their characters a moment: a question only their background could answer, a lock only they can pick. Say yes to creative plans when you can, and when you must say no, offer a way it could work. End the session on a moment people want to come back for, and ask afterwards what everyone enjoyed most. Then do more of that.

Most of all, remember the players want you to succeed. Nobody at the table expects a perfect first game; they expect a fun one.

Running it with ComeOnOver

PF2e Play keeps a campaign together: invite your players, see their characters, run combat and keep session notes in one place. Players build their characters for free in the PF2e Character Creator, every variant rule included, and the PF2e System Searcher answers a rules question in seconds when the table needs it.

Updated 2026-10-13. More guides · Open ComeOnOver