Running a play-by-post campaign

How to run a Pathfinder 2e campaign entirely in writing: the posting rhythm, what the GM tracks, how boons and the wiki keep a slow game alive, and the etiquette that keeps it fun.

Not every group can meet at the same table, or the same video call, every week. Play-by-post is the answer: the campaign happens in writing, a few posts a day, and everyone plays when they have a spare ten minutes. It suits busy adults, players in different time zones, and anyone who likes to think before their character speaks. This guide explains how a written campaign actually runs, what the game master keeps track of, and how ComeOnOver's PathWars tools hold it together.

How a written campaign moves

Play-by-post replaces the session with a stream of posts. The GM sets the scene in writing, each player replies with what their character does and says, and the GM resolves it and moves the scene on. A combat that takes an hour at a table can take a week in posts, and that is fine, because nobody had to be free on Tuesday. The rhythm that works for most tables is simple: the GM posts at least once a day, players post at least once a day, and nobody waits more than a day for anyone.

Dice still get rolled. Players roll their own checks and attacks and post the totals with their actions, so the GM can resolve a whole round from one pass of replies. The trust rule is the same as at a table: roll in the open, report what you got, and let the GM narrate the outcome. Anything secret, a hidden Perception check, a villain's saving throw, the GM rolls privately and reveals only what the characters would know.

What the GM tracks

A written game is easy to lose track of, because there is no table to look around. The experienced play-by-post GM keeps three lists pinned where everyone can see them:

Conditions deserve special care in writing, because nobody can see the tokens. When a monster is frightened or a character goes prone, say so in the post, every time, until it ends. "The ogre is still frightened (frightened 1)" costs the GM six words and saves the whole table an argument.

Boons keep a slow game alive

The enemy of play-by-post is drift: posts slow down, a player goes quiet, and the campaign stalls. Rewards fight drift, and PathWars campaigns have a built-in one: boons. The GM hands them out for good play, and players spend them later for an edge when it matters. A boon economy gives everyone a reason to post today rather than tomorrow, because today's clever post is tomorrow's reroll.

The PathWars tool is the campaign's dashboard between posts: the boons each player has earned and can spend, how the campaign is going overall, and what the GM is waiting on. That last one is the drift-killer. When the whole table can see that the game is waiting on two specific players, those players usually post the same day.

The wiki is the table's memory

A campaign that runs for months in writing builds up more story than anyone remembers. The PathWarsWiki reader keeps the player wiki readable: each campaign's pages, the rules the table uses, the characters, all searchable, with each page showing how long ago it was edited. New players catch up by reading instead of asking. Old players settle "wait, what did we promise the smugglers?" by searching instead of arguing.

Keep the wiki current as you play and it pays for itself. After each scene, the GM (or a volunteered chronicler) writes a paragraph: where the party went, what they learned, what they promised. Three sentences per scene is enough. Six months later that paragraph is the difference between a beloved long campaign and one nobody can reconstruct.

Table etiquette for writing

Starting yours

Begin with a short arc, not a saga: one location, one problem, a clear end after a few weeks of posts. Recruit one player more than you need, because written games lose people, and end the first arc with a decision point so continuing feels like a choice. Build the characters in the PF2e Character Creator, look up anything mid-game in the PF2e System Searcher, and run the campaign itself through PathWars, where the boons, the stats and the waiting list keep a slow game moving.

Updated 2026-11-11. More guides · Open ComeOnOver