One of the best things about Pathfinder Second Edition for a Game Master is that encounter building actually works. The game gives you a budget of experience points for each level of threat, and a price for every creature based on its level compared to the party's. Spend the budget and you get a fight of the difficulty you asked for, far more reliably than in most systems. This guide explains the budget, the prices, and how to turn them into encounters your players will remember.
The threat levels
Encounters come in five threat levels. The XP budgets below are for a party of four characters:
- Trivial: 40 XP or less. No real danger. Useful for showing off a new ability or warming up a session.
- Low: 60 XP. A fight the party should win comfortably, using a few resources.
- Moderate: 80 XP. The standard fight. A real challenge that costs the party something, but they should win.
- Severe: 120 XP. A hard fight, the kind for a boss or a climax. Bad luck or poor tactics can drop characters.
- Extreme: 160 XP. A desperate fight that could kill the party. Use rarely, and make sure the players have a way to retreat or change the odds.
What each creature costs
A creature's price depends only on its level compared to the party's level:
- Party level -4: 10 XP
- Party level -3: 15 XP
- Party level -2: 20 XP
- Party level -1: 30 XP
- Same as the party: 40 XP
- Party level +1: 60 XP
- Party level +2: 80 XP
- Party level +3: 120 XP
- Party level +4: 160 XP
Creatures more than four levels below the party are not worth counting; they are not a threat. Creatures more than four levels above it are beyond an extreme encounter and should be treated as something to avoid rather than fight.
Adjusting for party size
The budgets assume four characters. For each additional character, add to the budget: 10 XP for a trivial encounter, 20 XP for low or moderate, 30 XP for severe and 40 XP for extreme. For each character fewer than four, subtract the same amounts. A party of five facing a moderate fight has 100 XP to spend; a party of three has 60.
Worked examples for a level 3 party of four
- Moderate (80 XP), one strong foe: a single level 5 creature (party level +2) costs 80 XP. One big monster makes a dramatic fight, but beware: a single creature only gets one turn per round, and a level +2 enemy hits hard and resists a lot.
- Moderate (80 XP), a group: two level 3 creatures (40 XP each) is a fair, even fight.
- Moderate (80 XP), a mob: four level 1 creatures (20 XP each). Lots of actions on the enemy side and lots of targets for area spells.
- Severe (120 XP), a boss and minions: one level 4 creature (60 XP) and three level 1 creatures (60 XP). A leader with guards is one of the most satisfying shapes for a fight.
Making the numbers fun
The budget makes an encounter fair; it does not make it interesting. A few habits help:
- Vary the shape. Alternate single big monsters, even groups and swarms of weaker foes. Each plays very differently.
- Be careful with high-level solo monsters. A creature three or four levels above the party lands critical hits often and can drop a character in one turn. A severe or extreme fight against one creature is far swingier than the same budget spent on several.
- Use the terrain. Cover, high ground, narrow corridors, difficult terrain and hazards all change a fight without changing its budget. Hazards have their own XP value, so you can include them.
- Give the enemies a goal. Monsters that try to steal something, escape, protect a leader or complete a ritual make a fight more than an exchange of hits.
- Pace the day. A typical adventuring day might be a few low and moderate encounters with one severe one. Players spend resources across fights, so even a low encounter matters late in the day.
- Read the stat block first. Two creatures of the same level can be very different. A spellcaster with area spells is far more dangerous to a clustered party than a melee brute.
Awarding experience
The same numbers tell you how much XP to give: the party earns the XP of the encounter they overcame, and characters level up at 1,000 XP. Many groups skip XP entirely and level up at story milestones instead, which works just as well; the budget still tells you how hard each fight will be.
Using ComeOnOver to prepare
The PF2e System Searcher can filter by level and by sourcebook, such as Monster Core, which makes it quick to find candidates at exactly party level +1 or -2 when you are spending a budget. PF2e Play keeps your campaign, the party's characters and your session notes in one place, so you can see everyone's level and sheet while you plan.
Updated 2026-10-13. More guides · Open ComeOnOver